Sweet Tooth Candy and Ice Cream Boutique

Your Destination for Premium Ice Cream and local hand-made candy and fudge.

Make The Sweet Tooth Candy and Ice Cream Boutique your after-supper destination this season! The warm weather is finally here and there are thirty flavors of ice cream from which to choose.
find your favorite flavors
Premium Ingredients go into Buck's Premium Ice Cream!

Buck’s Ice Cream is Connecticut’s premier manufacturer and distributor of premium ice cream and other dessert products to the foodservice industry. We use only the finest ingredients available. Fresh Cream from local New England Farms, whole n...
see our story
Fascia's Chocolates

The Fascia Family continues to hand-craft the finest chocolates, using only the freshest all-natural ingredients. Each piece of chocolate that comes out of our candy kitchen is still made with the care and pride we have built our reputation on for t...
our story
Do you Remember Penny Candy?

Do you remember the days when you took your newspaper money down to the corner candy shop every Saturday afternoon?
visit our candy shop

Fascia's Chocolates

The Fascia Family continues to hand-craft the finest chocolates, using only the freshest all-natural ingredients. Each piece of chocolate that comes out of our candy kitchen is still made with the care and pride we have built our reputation on for the past 50 years!

Buck's Premium Ice Cream

Since Charles Buck, Sr. began delivering ice cream out of his pickup truck to restaurants in 1950, Buck’s Ice Cream has grown to become Connecticut’s premier Ice Cream manufacturer and distributor for the food service industry.

Phenomenal Fudge

Phenomenal Fudge® is a family operation in Shoreham, Vermont. In 1985 we opened a country store and soon noticed that we were selling more of our home made fudge than Vermont maple syrup.

A Destination Sweet Shop

The Sweet Tooth is Plymouth's premier candy and ice cream boutique. We guarantee you’ll find something in our store to satisfy your sweet tooth. Our one-of-a-kind candy and ice cream shop features candy in fun wooden crates all over the store, shelves stocked with the finest confections from around the area, and nostalgic treats you probably haven’t seen in years. Come taste the thirty flavors of Buck’s premium ice cream and other frozen dessert treats.

Buck's "La Favorita" Ice Cream
Fascia's Chocolates
Phenomenal Fudge
Old-Fashioned Penny Candies

We use only the finest ingredients available. Fresh Cream from local New England Farms, whole nuts, pure vanilla extract, dutch cocoa, and much more!

Phenomenal Fudge® is a family operation in Shoreham, Vermont. In 1985 we opened a country store and soon noticed that we were selling more of our home made fudge than Vermont maple syrup.

At the Sweet Tooth we have a very large selection of old school candy packed in fun wooden crates all over the store. You will get nostalgic while looking through all the treats. “This reminds me of…” will definitely be a common phrase during your visit.